The recreation of Chile’s most notable ecclesiastic scandal to date. Father Karadima runs a tight ship in his diocese in Santiago. He has huge premises, an imposing church, real estate and a supply of keen young acolytes. He is a charismatic and temperamental figure but as he is successful, Rome lets him get on with things. These things include sexual relationships with some of the young men, 5 of whom later reported him after decades of abuse. What this film does is distill the story into one experienced by a Tomas Leyton, who becomes enamoured of the priest and conflicted between his supposed desire to become a priest and the sexual awakening he has with Karadima.
The film, directed by Matias Lira is a sober affair, with the dull grainy camerawork of a society at first under a dictatorship and continually keen adherents to the Catholic church, a very influential force in society. Luis Gnecco does a very good job as the convincing but underlyingly nasty Karadima, Benjamin Vicuña has more of a battle to come across as the repentant adult and Pedro Campos is very effective as the younger Tomás.
My main complaint is with the flashbacks and the use of the two actors as Tomás. They are not always clear and the jump between the gauche boy and the young doctor is too big a jump. Some have criticised the film for not attacking the church more but I think Lira is more interested in trying to show how such people as Karadima can exert such a sway over others. He partially succeeds in this but is otherwise very successful in portraying a sensitive issue with respect.
★★★ +