This is one of the films that is allowing the shadow side of the US to emerge. As its title suggests, this is a pretty sorry tale set in the 40´s in the cotton belt of Mississippi with some very wet periods turning the ground to mud. And the values are pretty dirty too with racism and sexism the order of the day in this Ku Klux Klan run area. The story is that of a white family, somewhat brought down in life to running a cotton field with Laura the main voice in her family, a late-wed pianist who is forced to become a practical mother, miles from running water or electricity. Carey Mulligan does her best work ever here. Husband Henry (Jason Clarke) is a bit limited, at times with a good heart, at times scared of disobeying social mores and Pappy (Jonathan Banks) is your worst kind of racist. How Laura puts up with this is incredible. Henry’s brother Jamie (Garrett Hedlund) goes off to war as a fighter pilot and is a bit gutless too.
Meanwhile, their tenants and neighbours are the Jacksons: Hap (Rob Morgan, very strong), preacher and farmer, his wife Florence (played in stoic fashion by Mary J Blige), Ronsel (Jason Mitchell), the oldest son who goes to Europe in a tank company. Plus various other children. There are other neighbours too but their storylines are not developed much in this sprawling novel-like movie.
The guts of the film revolves around the two returning servicemen, who both shocked by their war experiences strike up a friendship which is frowned upon in this town and eventually challenged by some of the more racist locals. The message of the film is about how reaching out to others who understand allows us to overcome this racism and these two boys as also in the case of Florence and Laura shows that we can get along in these situations. Sadly, bigoted white men often get in the way. Director Dee Rees is making a comment about the US today as much as portraying its despicable past.
Filmwise, the story is captivating but somewhat unevenly told. I found the voiceovers and the editing a little confusing. Nonetheless Rees and co-screenwriter Virgil Williams get the story across. Rachel Morrrison gives us some excellent photography of the rural setting and Mary J Blige chimes in with a powerful song at the end.
Not a perfect film but one that opens the social conscience widely and judging from the States today one that is indeed necessary.
∇∇∇∇