I would like to report that Lucrecia Martel’s first film in nine years is a masterpiece but contrary to some critics I fear that it is not. The talented Argentine captures what it must be like inside someone’s head better than most directors. She has a way with sound second to none and her staging and use of colour is excellent.
This film takes place during the Spanish colonization of Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay, etc and focuses on a lowly Spanish civil servant operating out of a village near Asuncion. It is a hot dirty place and he is the local magistrate. He left his family in Spain and longs to get out of this dump but governors come and go and no progress is made with his request for transfer. Life in this place is excellently conveyed in the movie, the hovels of the locals living basically in the open air and the residences of the Spaniards which are little better, damp and unprivate. Many small details of daily life are portrayed plus moments of more existential like the appearance of a boy who is like a seer and the scene of a llama walking through a government office.
In the last and tragic part of the film, Diego de Zama (Daniel Fernandez Cacho, suitably wry) decides to join a ragbag group of men heading off to try to catch a local bandit and get the bounty for him. This ill-founded expedition is at once beautiful as it goes through amazing scenery and encounters the natives and harrowing as they get more and more embroiled in violence. Martel does handle it beautifully though.
My problem with the movie is that it is too one-paced and too dense with detail. We need changes of speed and some scenes that are emptier so we can breathe. And her attention to feelings rather than a story also hinders the ability of the viewer to connect with the film. Martel does tend to have isolated characters and there is only so much story that they can handle. Here, the moments with the Minister’s wife (Lola Dueñas) and with the governors are probably the best because we get to see the machinations of the society and of how this colony was ruled. I’d like to give it more but the pace and the distance we felt from the film distracted me. Nonetheless she has real talent as a director and there are several unforgettable scenes.
★★★+