This film sank without much trace in 2011 but it is not so bad as to deserve complete oblivion. The director is a great grandchild of Charles Darwin, Matthew Chapman and he is a staunch believer in the power of science. He made this film to provide some sort of debate between religious faith and atheism. It doesn’t always work and it is very contrived in parts but at least he gets the subject out there.
Gavin (Charlie Hunnam) is a hotel manager who lives with his gay flatmate. Later we discover Gavin has had tragedy in his recent life and is trying to put his life together. He is an atheist and is trying to make sense of it all without a religion. In the same block of flats are a couple Joe (Patrick Wilson) and Shana (Liv Tyler) who also have backstories. Joe is deeply religious and Shana passively accepts this as part of her debt to Joe. From the beginning the neighbour’s relationship is fraught and when Joe insinuates that Gavin and his flatmate are sinners being gay, Gavin, who is straight decides to seduce Shana. The first half of the movie meanders along quite nicely in this way within the framework of flashbacks as we start the story with Gavin high up on the ledge of a building threatening to jump. In his talk with Hollis (Terrence Howard), the detective on his case trying to talk him down we start to learn the whole story. As a sort of rather unnecessary subplot, Hollis himself is having an existential crisis having discovered that very morning that he is sterile from birth but somehow father of two children!
All this goes on hurtling towards a midday deadline when Gavin says he will jump, a decision prompted by a challenge from Joe. Enough said as the last part of the movie turns into a sort of thriller, which actually works all right but is at odds with the rest of the movie.
So, messy direction, very obvious set speeches and some very uneven characters (Gavin and Shana are well-drawn but Joe is a complete 2-D cliché who needs fleshing out). Hollis’s story just smacks of Hollywood schmaltz. Photography is good and the mood in an unnamed city but set in a rather seedy Baton Rouge sort of fits. The blind faith of the Christians is rather overwritten but there is a nice scene dueling with parts of the Bible. Good acting considering the script, especially from Hunnam and Howard.
♦♦