Monthly Archives: December 2016

Mr Church

Standard

church4

Another veteran Aussie director, Bruce Beresford is back with a weepie.  This time it is about a woman dying of cancer (elegant Natasha McElhone)church2, whose benefactor arranges for Church (Eddie Murphy, correct) to come and cook for her and her young daughter.  The daughter is at first resistant, then eventually accepts him.church6  Mother dies, daughter goes off to uni, gets pregnant and goes back “home” to where Church continues ensconced.  Daughter has a girl and the cycle more or less begins again.church5 Britt Robertsonchurch1 plays the daughter as a young woman.  As you would expect from Beresford, the production is professional.  The trouble is the story is clichéd and twee, we’ve seen it all before in its attempt to pull our heartstrings and cement old stereotypes about service, race, single mothers, you name it.  Worth it to see Murphy church3back on screen but please make a comedy next time!

★★

Court

Standard

court5

Narayan Kamble is an ageing teacher and part-time protest singer.  A sort of folk protester about the state of the world.  This film focuses on a rambling trial in which he is accused of inciting suicide.court1  The victim is a sewers worker who has tenuous connections with the accused but a whole case is trumped up to keep him in custody.  This in turn is an excuse to look at the highly inefficient Indian justice system: the caprices of the judges,court6 the application of outdated laws, the police who lose or lack any evidence,court4 the prosecutors laying charges and failing to show the connections, the treatment of people according to their caste, bought witnesses, disappeared witnesses, the long delays between hearings and the absurd bail rules.  Chaitanya Tamhane gives it both barrels but in a charming almost absurdist way.  He also gives us a look into the private lives of the protagonists. The prosecutor (Geetanjali Kulkarni) is a conservative mother who is basically a slave at home when not in court. court2 Defence attorney Vora (Vivek Gomber) is more westernized and much more liberal but sits uncomfortably between both worlds. Kamble (Vira Sathidar) is totally credible as the elderly protest singer and the main judge is seen in his private life more clearly than in court.  What we see is an inept and corrupt system desperately needing an overhaul court3as in many developing countries with some touches related to modern India.  It certainly makes you think and is a very promising debut film.

★★★★+

Son of Saul

Standard

saul3

Coming back down after this extraordinary experience.  Not a nice film as regards the setting and topic but as a holocaust film with a difference, this certainly gives us a new angle.  Basically, we are in the concentration camp with the Sommenkommandos, the Jewish prisoners doing the dirty work for the Nazis, stripping the incoming prisoners, shoving them into the gas chambers, going through their clothes for money and cleaning the place after the gassing.saul1  They too are on borrowed time and while they try to plan means of escape, they could be replaced at any time.  We follow Saul, who upon seeing a dead boy, takes him as his son and is determined to find a rabbi to give him a proper Jewish burial.  This is complete madness in the camp but we follow him obsessed with his goal piecing together the bits to do it.saul4  It is an act of defiance and hope but equally hard to understand from this unassuming man.  No matter.  It is a way of seeing life in the camp in what must be one of the most authentic films made of that subject.  Rookie director Laszlo Nemes produces a very good film indeed in his first work, Matias Erdely as the cameraman makes 100 minutes of hand held camera bearablesaul6 and justified and Geza Rohrig as Saul is a study in the human condition.saul5  A very important piece of cinema, maybe not the most exciting or entertaining but one that takes us to a place which feels like 100% authentic.

★★★★★

Sully

Standard

sully3

Workmanlike reconstruction of the miraculous landing in the Hudson River of a US Airlines jet in 2009, without loss of life.sully1  The film is part rerun of the water-based landing and part investigation of the accident afterwards in which the investigators and insurance companies, airlines, etc., try to place more blame on the pilot, Chesley Sullenberger.  Tom Hanks sully5does another great job as the humble and principled ´Sully´ and is ably assisted by Aaron Eckhart as his co-pilot.sully5  Laura Linney has less of a good role as a simpering wife. sully4Clint Eastwood directs with his usual aplomb and economy but I can´t help feeling that he has to stretch the material a bit.sully6  The movie has its moments particularly in the rescue scenes but then it is all over!

★★★★

Carnage

Standard

carnage1

Roman Polanski takes this successful stage play of Yasmina Reza and puts it on the screen with four excellent actors.  Set in New York but shot in Paris, it is a chamber piece in which two sets of parents meet to discuss an incident involving their sons in which one hit and hurt the other.carnage2  Their supposed civilized attitude quickly breaks down and both the gap between them in income and the strains in each marriage start to show.  Billed by some as a comedy, I found it more tragic than that.  So, a pretty good script and direction which start to flag in the last part.  Jodie Foster as the wound up liberal Pen is particularly effectivecarnage4 as is Kate Winslet as the investment broker, Nancy. carnage3 Christoph Waltz is not far behind carnage5but his accent gives him away at times and John C Reilly is his usual cheerful character who then loses it too.carnage6  All round it is a bit of a talkie but you know that when you start watching it.  I’ve seen worse film adaptations though.

★★★★

The Connection

Standard

connect4

A French version of the battle between a magistrate and the Marseilles mafia in the 1970´s who had all sorts of protection rackets and trafficking going.connect1  I didn’t see the award winning Gene Hackman film and while this has been less hailed as a movie, I still enjoyed it a lot despite the theme.  Cedric Jimenez does a good job of recreating the era and we forget how dependent we were the telephone.  The sunny Midi skies connect2contrast with the drugs, the new discos and the violence.  The film is basically a war between Pierre Michel (Jean Dujardin)connect3, magistrate appointed to wage war on the mafia and local hotshot Tony Zampa (Gilles Lelouche).connect6  Each has his team and not all are loyal.  The tentacles of crime are all over and we see this at the political level too.  We also get to see the family life of each manconnect5, so that they are almost mirror images of the other.  The script is smart enough, it moves along briskly though the editing is a little too brusque at times and the music and photography all add to the effect.  It may not be a great piece of cinema but it combines sufficient doses of action and excitement and historical accuracy to be a satisfying couple of hours spent in the south of France.

★★★★

Zulu

Standard

zulu3

I just discovered that the director of this Jérome Salle was screenplay writer of The Tourist, one of the worst action thrillers I’ve seen in years.  This may explain my mixed feelings towards this film.  Zulu is set in Cape Town and is a thriller involving police trying to find the motives for homicides in the city.zulu2  This leads them to a ring that is producing some sort of chemical drugs which are being tested on young and especially poor people.  It’s an interesting storyline with good acting led by an unrecognizable Orlando Bloomzulu1, the ever reliable Forest Whitaker and some competent locals.zulu5

But….I did not like the extreme brutal violence, which seems often unnecessary to show and a certain stereotyping of people and motives for purposes of the plot.zulu6  It does not show South Africa in a good light which may be valid enough.zulu4

Having said all that it moves along pacily enough, the production values are sound and there are some moments of much tension.  A rating with reservations.

★★★

Mi Gran Noche

Standard

gran6

This is a fast moving farce and satire on television and modern society is by talented Spanish director Alex de la Iglesia and is one of his least black movies.  Set in a television studio in October where they are doing the advanced filming of the New Year’s Eve countdown complete with actors as the audiencegran4, false drinks (though someone is selling it contraband) and loads of glitter and glamour.  Various storylines run deftly through the film including the rivalry between veteran divo Alphonso (played by Raphael as a reflection of himself)gran1 and Adanne (Mario Casas) a sort of cross between a younger Chayanne and David Bisbal.gran3  Then the two presenters who are married but in a constant state of wargran5, the producer played by Carmen Machi as a bolshy lesbian,gran7 the plot to kill Alphonso by his very own adopted son who has hired Oscar to kill him but discovers that Oscar is a great fan.  The central story is about José (Pepón Nieto), a plump ageing mother’s boy who discovers love at his table with the black widow Paloma( Blanca Suárez), who seems to bring bad luck to the men she is near.gran2  All of this plays out to a backdrop of protests and riots against the government outside the studio.

As a metaphor of the modern world and the mess we are in, this is a very astute film, full of both visual and black humour.

★★★★

El Ciudadano Ilustre

Standard

ciudadano5

I watched El Ciudadano Ilustre (The Distinguished Citizen), an Argentine film nominated for the Oscars. It concerns a Nobel Laureate for literature (Oscar Martinez, very competent)ciudadano1 who returns to his small town birthplace in Argentina to receive the prize of the title of the film and discovers that under the surface the same small town hypocrisiesciudadano3 that made him flee to Spain are still alive and kicking. He too has many of these attitudes, softened by decades in Europe but likely to flair up again.  In this very dark comedy, we see how his visit home becomes a nightmare. It may not be a perfect film but the directors (Gaston Duprat and Mariano Cohn) and scriptwriter (Andrés Duprat) manage to juggle a number of expressions of small town life and of Argentine life in particular. Apart from the hypocrisy and thuggery, there is also an interesting line in transgressions with people either breaking the rulesciudadano6, taking short cuts or disrespecting the other. All very common behaviours here in Argentina and often resulting in harm.  The selfishness with which many act and their lack of thought and consideration for the other is clearly spelt out but how well the public will capture this message I don’t know.  Dady Brievaciudadano4, Andrea Frigeriociudadano2 and Manuel Vicente as the mayor all give good support.  Not a perfect film and not one that will be loved by all but a necessary commentary on life here.

★★★★

The Way Back

Standard

way3

I am a great fan of Peter Weir.  He has produced some of my favourite films ever: Gallipoli, The Year of Living Dangerously, Witness, Fearless and so on.  This film from 2010 was his first in seven years and the latest, so who knows if any more features are on the way. The Way Back is based on a novel by Slawomir Rawicz called The Long Walk telling the story of some escapees from a Gulag in Siberiaway1 who set off to walk to India via both the icy steppes of Siberia and the Gobi desert, before crossing the Himalayas.way5  Aspersions on the veracity of this trek which was supposedly true have since been cast but it made for a great story.  Weir captures some of that through the beautiful landscapes but I came away feeling that the film lacked something.  Most of all was better characterization of a bunch of people who were perhaps not so easy to open.  That Colin Farrell way2playing the thief Valka is the most interesting of the bunch says a lot.  The acting is good enough with Ed Harris and his weathered face a great anchorway6jpg, Saoirse Ronan, a surprisingly effective Irena and Jim Sturgess as the leader Janusz amongst a bunch of Easter Europeans.way4  Trouble is they don’t have much to work with and once the film gets out of the Gulag it is really just one climatic trial after another. way7 Makeup perhaps do best in conveying the hell of this journey but only in brief moments do we get much of the psychological side.  So, a disappointment in part.  Sure, it’s a solid film, Weir wouldn’t give us less but there is nothing that really inspires or is admirable in this.

★★★+